Commemorating death in European artistic music
Authors
Anna G. Piotrowska
Abstract
The commemoration of death via music needs to be discussed in two
dimensions: the first one refers to (1) musical stage works such as operas and ballets
where extra – musical, i.e. textual and visual factors play important role and (2)
instrumental music in which death can be portrayed by means of musical tools. The
strategies of presenting death in musical stage works I would like to analyze with
respect to the most common pairs of tropes where death is coupled with love, honour,
and sin.
Death and love seems the most common topic of various operas and ballets
stemming its popularity from the first Baroque operas depicting the story of Orfeo and
Eurydice. The inseparable link of Thanatos and Eros in operas was often connected
with murders (Verdi’s Rigoletto), killings and suicides (Puccini’s Tosca). Death and
honour in musical stage works are often used while portraying historical events. Death
symbolizes the ultimate solution and as such is reserved for the very end of the work
(Erkel’s Huynadi Laszlo). Death and evil is connected in musical stage works again with
depiction of murders, suicides but also quite often is linked with redemption of sins
(Verdi’s Traviata). The allegoric versus eristic attempts to capture the moment of death
in musical works will be also discussed. In the conclusion of the first section I would
like to ponder on musical tools used by composers of different times in order to depict
death musically, ranging from the extremely loud dynamics and tutti of the orchestra,
alternatively the use of certain (harbingering death) instruments – to leaving the
moment of death completely silent (Copland’s Billy the Kid).
The second section of my paper will be dedicated to instrumental music
composed for commemorating the death. Funeral music will be presented in respect to
the tradition of the funeral mass – Requiem and additionally the idea of depicting death
by means of notes will be presented. In the so called doctrine of musical figures the
term prosopopoeia was used to denote rhetorical personification of the deceased, e.g. in
funerary oratories. Composers were often asked (also by their own pupils) to compose,
for example, funeral motets. Some composers wrote their own funeral music during
their life. The paper will be richly illustrated with examples form European artistic
music form the period 18th – 20th century.
Keywords
music, death, commemoration, Europe, love